Review: The Duke's Dearest Dilemma (Willful Wainwrights #1) by Wendy LaCapra
When the Duke of Harbury swept sweet, mild-mannered Cassandra Wainwright into a scandalous waltz at Almack's, he only wished to mask a much older heartbreak from the ton’s prying eyes. But his rash act didn’t just destroy Cassandra’s future, it threatened the security of her four orphaned sisters. Honor-bound, he accepts her proposed marriage of convenience, while internally vowing to protect his shattered heart.
Marriage’s stark intimacy strips away Cassie's gentle façade, revealing a fiery soul neither she nor Harbury expected. At the same time, his small gestures of consideration and irresistible kisses reveal a devastatingly captivating man beneath his reserved exterior. And so, Cassie finds herself trapped between her newly awakened fury and her deepening desire as estate troubles mount, unearthing secrets that threaten their tentative bond.
Now, to save all they hold dear, Harbury and Cassandra must decide how much of their guarded hearts they are willing to risk.
This book was incredibly difficult for me to get into, due in part to the fact that Cassandra seriously annoyed me. And honestly, I think a lot of that comes down to the fact that she knew exactly what she was getting herself into. She knew Edward's affections belonged to someone else when they married. She claims to have been “in love” with him before their marriage, which is apparently why she “wanted him for herself,” but then she proceeds to be such a miserable witch once they actually get married that I spent a good portion of the book wondering what exactly Edward saw in her.
Granted, Edward doesn't know how she supposedly feels about him. And to be completely honest, neither did I because we're never really given any reason to believe that Cassandra holds him in particularly high esteem. But again, she's the one who proposed a marriage of convenience while knowing he was in love with another woman. So I'm sorry, but what exactly did she expect? She goes into this marriage knowing Edward's heart belongs to someone else and then seems genuinely offended when he doesn't immediately behave like the husband she's apparently imagined in her head. But again, she treats him so horribly I'm surprised he was as civil to her as he was.
For example, they consummate their marriage, and then she orders him out of her room. He tries to apologize, and she not only brushes him off, but basically tells him to shut up in his own house the next morning at breakfast. I'm sorry, but that doesn't exactly inspire me to want to spend more time with you. And then she thinks to herself that she won't allow his “obvious good will” to “mute her anger.” Girl. Why are you angry?! You knowingly married a man who loved someone else, proposed a marriage that was supposed to be one of convenience, and then spent the beginning of that marriage pushing him away at every opportunity. At some point, you're going to have to acknowledge that you're contributing to the problem.
Of course, Edward isn't exactly innocent here either. For starters, he's constantly comparing his wife to Viv. Thankfully, most of these comparisons happen in his own head, because can you imagine if he were actually saying them out loud? But he's also withholding secrets from Cassandra. And not just little things. These are secrets he KNOWS will hurt her when the truth eventually comes out, yet he continues making excuses for why he hasn't told her. That's not exactly a recipe for a healthy marriage. And naturally, when the truth finally does come out and Viv shows up at Edward's estate asking for his help because her father is missing, Cassandra does what pretty much every romance heroine has done since the dawn of time.
She runs away to her married sister's house. Except, apparently, she's also upset that Edward doesn't chase after her. I'm sorry...What?
You literally said you didn't want to be chased. Then you're melancholy because he didn't chase you. Give me a break. This entire relationship could have been significantly less frustrating if these two had simply sat down and talked to each other. Revolutionary concept I know. Instead, we get misunderstandings, withheld information, assumptions, anger, hurt feelings, and people storming off while expecting the other person to somehow magically know what they actually want.
And then we get to the so-called epilogue. Except I'm not entirely sure what the heck it was supposed to be. Why do I care about Cassandra's siblings and their potential matches? By this point, even some of the relationships that had been hinted at earlier felt completely superfluous. And I'm sorry, but the guardian/ward trope is already weird enough for me without having it shoved into what was supposed to be the conclusion of someone else's love story. I wanted to see Edward and Cassandra's happily-ever-after. That's why I was reading this book. I did not need several pages about what kind of mischief her sisters might be getting themselves into next.
Overall, this wasn't a terrible read, but it was definitely a frustrating one. There was potential here, and I think I would have enjoyed it considerably more if Cassandra and Edward had spent less time assuming what the other was thinking and more time actually communicating.



Post a Comment
0 Comments